Back to Research

    How Dealer Badges Are Calculated

    All dealer badges are generated using deterministic, algorithmic scoring. No dealer can pay to influence badge outcomes. Badges are compared only within the current result set for a given product, weight, quantity, and payment method selection.

    BadgeInputsFormulaTie-breakersMin Eligibility
    Best SupportDealer support typePhone + Chat = 100, Phone = 80, Chat = 70, Not specified = 0Lower landed cost, then older established yearScore > 0
    Best LongevityEstablished yearCurrent year − established year. Highest tenure wins.Lower landed costNone
    Best for First-Time BuyersLanded cost proximity, support, secure packaging, tenureCost within 3% of cheapest = 30, Phone + Chat = 30, Secure packaging = 20, 10+ years = 20Lower landed cost, then older established yearComposite score ≥ 75
    Best for Secure ShippingPackaging, insurance, signature policySecure/discreet packaging = 50, Insured shipping = 30, Signature policy = 20Lower landed costScore > 0
    Best Optimization OpportunitySavings thresholds, additional quantity neededTotal savings = 50%, Per-coin savings = 30%, Fewest extra coins = 20%Higher total savingsAt least one optimization breakpoint exists

    Strongest Overall Value

    The "Strongest Overall Value" designation uses a weighted composite score across five dimensions:

    • Cost Competitiveness40% weight — Normalized 0–100 scale where the lowest landed cost = 100
    • Support Quality20% weight — Based on support type scoring
    • Secure Shipping15% weight — Packaging, insurance, signature policy
    • Longevity15% weight — Normalized against longest-tenured dealer in set
    • Optimization Potential10% weight — Whether savings breakpoints exist

    Scoring Principles

    • All scores are deterministic and reproducible for the same inputs
    • No paid badge overrides — badges are algorithmic only
    • Dealers are compared only within the current result set
    • Tie-breakers are applied consistently: lower landed cost first, then older established year

    Badges are generated using objective scoring rules based on landed cost, support, dealer tenure, shipping security, and optimization opportunities. No dealer can pay to influence badge outcomes.